Motivation to Treatment Participation and Its Correlation with Demographic and Clinical Profile of Inpatients Diagnosed with Substance Use Disorders

Author(s): Bivin J. B (MSN)1 & Riaz K. M (Ph. D N)2
Email(s):  bivin.jb@gmail.com
Author Details :
1. Ph. D Nursing Scholar under National Consortium for Ph. D in Nursing by Indian Nursing Council, New Delhi
2. Assistant Professor, Government College of Nursing, Ernakulam, Kerala.
Published In:   Volume – 3,      Issue – 1,     Year – 2025 (JAN-JUN)
How to cite this article? Bivin JB, Riaz KM. Motivation to treatment participation and its correlation with demographic and clinical profile of inpatients diagnosed with substance use disorders. Int J Adv Res Med Nurs Health Sci. 2025 Jan-Jun;3(3):40-8. Available from: www.ijarmnhs.in
Motivation to Treatment Participation and Its Correlation with Demographic and Clinical Profile of Inpatients Diagnosed with Substance Use Disorders Bivin J. B (MSN)1 & Riaz K. M (Ph. D N)2
  1. D Nursing Scholar under National Consortium for Ph. D in Nursing by Indian Nursing Council, New Delhi
  2. Assistant Professor, Government College of Nursing, Ernakulam, Kerala.
  Author for Correspondence: Bivin J. B, bivin.jb@gmail.com

ABSTRACT
Aim: The study aimed to recognize demographic, and clinical predictors of motivation to treatment participation among inpatients diagnosed with substance use disorders (SUDs).
Methods: The study involved patients with substance use disorders (SUDs) who completed the Stages of Change Readiness and Treatment Eagerness Scale (SOCRATES 8D) along with a researcher-developed General Information Questionnaire (GIQ). Demographic and clinical data were collected using the GIQ. A total of 135 consenting subjects were included in the study.
Results: Analysis showed that mean SOCRATES 8D scores were significantly (p=0.01) higher among subjects with post-graduation and above levels of education (39.28±4.88) than those with no formal education (36.583±4.17).
Conclusion: Patients with SUDs often relapse due to low motivation to follow treatment and maintain sobriety.
Keywords: Motivation, Substance Use Disorders
Introduction Substance use disorders (SUDs) are defined by an unhealthy pattern of psychoactive substance use, which adversely affects an individual’s social and psychological functioning. This can result in dependence syndrome, characterized by behavioral, cognitive, and physical dysfunctions. SUDs pose a significant global challenge with far-reaching implications for public health. Notably, young people tend to misuse substances more frequently than older individuals. A substantial percentage of suicides, homicides, and incidents of domestic violence can be traced back to substance misuse. Addiction often compromises judgment, and individuals in a desperate pursuit of drugs can become dangerous. The drug crisis has escalated alarmingly in Kerala, as evidenced by a sudden increase in narcotic, abkari, and COTPA cases reported in the state in 2022..(1) The initiation of substance use is often voluntary; however, chronic substance use can severely impair an individual’s self-control. It involves taking proactive steps, making informed decisions, and possessing confidence in the ability to cease substance use. Motivation for participation in treatment is reflected in therapeutic adherence, compliance, and engagement in the treatment process. This significantly influences relapse rates in substance use by equipping individuals with an understanding of the mechanisms that contribute to sustainable, positive outcomes. Recovering from substance dependence is influenced by factors such as self-empowerment and motivation. The motivation to seek treatment is an important first step in understanding why patients want to change. Since addiction has both physical and mental aspects, individuals with substance use disorders have strong reasons to stop using drugs, which helps lower their chances of relapse. (2) This study will examine the demographic, clinical, and socioeconomic factors that affect motivation for treatment among inpatients with substance use disorders (SUDs).
Aim of the study Detect demographic, and clinical predictors of motivation to treatment participation among inpatients diagnosed with substance use disorders.
Objectives
  • Assess the demographic and clinical profile of inpatients diagnosed with SUDs.
  • Determine the motivation to treatment participation among inpatients diagnosed with SUDs.
  • Identify demographic, and clinical correlates with motivation to treatment participation among inpatients diagnosed with SUDs.
Methodology This study used a descriptive correlation research design. It was conducted in psychiatric units that focus on substance abuse in mental health facilities in Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala. The study used purposive sampling. Prospective subjects were screened, and consenting subjects who met the selection criteria were recruited. Subjects were selected based on the following selection criteria.
  • aged between 18 to 45 years
  • able to comprehend Malayalam or English
  • willing to participate in follow-up
The research instruments used in this study were General Information Questionnaire (GIQ) The GIQ is a 30-question guide created from research and experience. It collects personal details, substance use, and treatment history from patients. The questions are grouped into five categories: personal info, family and social relationships, substance use history, substance use pattern, and treatment history. The Stages of Change Readiness and Treatment Eagerness Scale (SOCRATES-8D) The SOCRATES-8D measures how willing people are to get help for substance use issues. It has 19 questions, and each question is answered on a scale from 0 to 4, where 0 means strongly disagree and 4 means strongly agree. Higher scores show more motivation to seek treatment. The tool gives three scores: Recognition, Ambivalence, and Taking Steps. Psychometric testing shown the following psychometric properties of the 19-item SOCRATES.
Table 1. Psychometrics of SOCRATES 8D
Factor No. of items (Items) Cronbach alpha Test-retest reliability
Intraclass Pearson
Recognition 7 (1,3,7,10,12,15,17) 0.60 – 0.88 0.82 0.83
Ambivalence 4 (2,6,11,16) 0.85 – 0.95 0.88 0.94
Taking steps 8 (4,5,8,9,13,14,18,19) 0.83 – 0.96 0.91 0.93
Reviewed literature shows that SOCRATES 8D has been utilized in many recent studies done among the Indian population.(4-7) RESULTS The demographic and clinical profiles of the subjects were assessed on the General Information Questionnaire (GIQ). The data were analysed using descriptive statistics and presented in terms of Frequency (f) and Percentage. Socio-demographic profile of the subjects All subjects were males. Most were married. Many had two children, while a few had three or more. Most had high school education and worked part-time. The average age was 34.49 years. The average monthly income was ₹.20632.35. Pattern of Substance Use The average age when people first used the substance was 25.49 years. Most subjects used substances daily. The most common substance abused is alcohol (100%), then tobacco (68.88%), and cannabis (16.30%). Most (82.96%) tried to quit substances within a year. Thirteen subjects had legal issues related to substance use. Five subjects in the study were imprisoned for substance use. Treatment and Subjective Perception Most of the subjects in the study were hospitalized for less than a week before. Many felt they needed hospitalization and treatment for over a week. A lot of subjects thought their health was poor. Some reported feeling pressured to get treatment for their substance use issues. SOCRATES 8D scores with socio-demographic and clinical profile The association of overall motivation to addiction treatment scores and selected personal variables at baseline measurement using SOCRATES 8D is presented in Table 2.
Table 2. Association of overall SOCRATES 8D scores and selected personal variables
Variables MAT Scores Test of Significance
M±SD F value p-value
Marital status
Single 37.11±5.99 0.22 0.92
Married 37.93±5.63
Separated 39.00±3.28
Divorced 37.57±6.77
Widowed 38.00±5.68
Number of children
No children 37.48±5.77 0.58 0.61
One 35.00±3.79
Two 38.11±5.71
Three 37.50±9.19
Highest level of education
No formal education 36.58±4.17 3.43 0.01
High school 36.40±5.24
Graduation 39.61±6.48
Post-Graduation and above 39.28±4.88
Employment status
Unemployed 39.15±5.17 1.28 0.28
Part-time job 38.18±6.12
Full-time job 36.40±5.67
Self-employed 37.80±5.06
Analysis showed that people with post-graduation education had higher SOCRATES 8D scores (39.28±4.88) compared to those with no formal education (36.583±4.17). There was no significant link between motivation to addiction treatment and factors like marital status (p=0.92), number of children (p=0.61), and employment status (p=0.28).
Table 3. Association of SOCRATES 8D scores and family/social Relationships
Variables MAT Scores Test of Significance
M±SD F-value p-value
Currently staying with
Parents 37.25±5.99 0.28 0.88
Relatives 38.60±6.65
Alone 39.25±1.48
Spouse 37.81±5.83
Friends 36.83±5.34
Analysis showed no significant link between overall motivation for addiction treatment and family/social relationships (p=0.88) at the start. Table 4 shows the link between SOCRATES 8D scores and substance use patterns.
Table 4. Association of SOCRATES 8D scores and pattern of substance use
Variables MAT Scores Test of Significance
M±SD Test value p-value
Frequency of alcohol use
Daily 37.90±5.90 0.96** 0.42
Weekly 36.77±5.05
Monthly 37.36±5.26
Types of other substances used
Tobacco 37.56±5.60 0.96** 0.71
Cannabis 36.47±5.25
No other substances 37.34±5.06
Previous attempts to quit substance use within one year
Yes 37.69±5.84 0.01* 0.89
No 36.98±5.68
Legal involvement in relation to substance use
Yes 38.00±5.62 0.03* 0.94
No 37.70±5.68
Imprisonment in relation to substance use
Yes 38.00±5.31 0.17* 0.85
No 37.68±5.73
Duration of imprisonment
Less than six months 37.10±5.71 0.16* 0.96
More than six months 37.57±5.78
*t-test; **ANOVA
The analysis revealed no significant correlation between the average SOCRATES 8D scores and various factors, including the frequency of substance use (p=0.42), the types of substances utilized (p=0.71), previous attempts to quit within the last year (p=0.89), legal complications associated with substance use (p=0.94), incarceration due to substance misuse (p=0.85), and the duration of imprisonment (p=0.96). DISCUSSION The study only included male participants, with no females in any of the study areas. This matches earlier research, including the National Family Health Survey-5 (NFHS-5), which shows more addiction among males.(8) Similar findings were seen in studies about substance use in Kerala.(9,10) A survey in Mizoram found that most respondents (89.4%) were males.(11) Similar patterns have been noted in different states in India.(12) Recently, more females with substance use issues are seeking help in general hospitals. However, cultural barriers may stop women from getting help. Also, the low number of female patients in de-addiction centers may be due to feelings of embarrassment and shame from social stigma. In this study, most of the subjects had two children. Similar results were found in another study in Kerala. The literacy rate for people aged seven and older in Kerala is 96.1%, and most of the subjects finished high school. Another study on alcohol abusers found that many patients were school dropouts. Our results agree with other studies that showed most patients were educated only up to primary or secondary level. However, some reports say that as literacy increases, the rate of abuse also increases, with the highest rates seen among graduates. Most subjects in both the experimental and control groups had part-time jobs.   The average age of the subjects was 34.49 years in this study. Similar results were found in other studies in India. This matches the Drug Abuse Monitoring System, which showed that most (70%) of the abusers were aged 21–40 years. The average monthly income was ₹20,632.35. Kerala has a low poverty rate of 0.6%. Districts like Ernakulam and Kottayam have very little poverty. Recent reports say Kerala’s per capita income is about 2.6 lakh in 2023, which is higher than Maharashtra and much more than the Indian average.   Pattern of Substance Use Most subjects reported using substances daily and often more than one type. The most common substance abused is alcohol, followed by tobacco and cannabis. Similar results were found in a study by Prajapati BB et al. and Gyanendra Raghuvanshi et al. A community study in Kerala found that 9.5% of people currently use alcohol. In this study, most subjects tried to quit using substances within a year, similar to findings by Gul and Sharma, where 33.0% made one attempt to stop. Stohs ME and others noted that peer pressure and cravings are major reasons why people struggle to stay sober. Thirteen people in the experimental group and twelve in the control group had legal issues related to substance use. Research in forensic psychiatry has shown a strong link between violent offenders and substance abuse. The current study also noted imprisonment due to legal problems from substance use. Most subjects in our study started using the substance before age 30, similar to earlier studies. The stress, competitiveness, identity issues, and emotional problems faced by this age group may combine with genetic factors to lead to substance use.   Treatment and Subjective Perception In this study, most people said they felt pressured to get treatment for their substance use problems. This is similar to many other studies where the reasons were social issues or pressure from family and friends. This may be due to patients’ cravings and loss of control, which makes it hard for them to seek help early and often leads to forced admissions. However, 77.04% of the participants felt that hospitalization was necessary, and treatment lasted more than a week, with many considering their health status as poor.   Research shows that environmental, developmental, and personality factors are linked to motivation for addiction treatment. This study found a significant link between motivation for addiction treatment and the education level of the participants. No significant relationships were found between overall motivation scores and factors like marital status, number of children, employment status, and family/social relationships at the start. In contrast, age and personality traits have been shown to influence patient motivation for addiction treatment in other studies.   CONCLUSION Patients with substance use disorders (SUDs) often relapse because they lack motivation to stick to treatment and stay sober. Teaching and counseling are important parts of psychiatric nursing care, but nurses and healthcare providers can also offer personalized care and help patients understand addiction management. It is crucial for patients with SUDs to have the right information to avoid putting their own lives and their families’ lives at risk. References
  1. Sunders B, Latt NC. Diagnostic definitions and classification of substance use disorders in the Textbook of addiction treatment. Springer New York. 2 nd Ed., 2021; 91-113.
  2. Bagheri Sheykhangafshe, F., Tajbakhsh, K., Savabi Niri, V., Eghbali, F., & Shabahang, R. (2023). The effectiveness of motivational enhancement therapy for addiction treatment and attitudinal ambivalence towards addiction. Journal of Research in Psychopathology, 4(12), 9-16.
  3. Miller, W. R., & Tonigan, J. S. Assessing drinkers’ motivation for change: The Stages of Change Readiness and Treatment Eagerness Scale (SOCRATES). Psychol Addict Behav. 1996; 10:81-89.
  4. McNeely J, Wang SS, Rostam Abadi Y, et al. Addiction Consultation Services for Opioid Use Disorder Treatment Initiation and Engagement: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Intern Med. 2024; 2321.
  5. Prajapati BB, Dedun MR, Jalfava H, Shukla A. A study of socio-demographic profile and pattern of drug use among substance abusers attending mind care de-addiction center in Ahmedabad. Int J Community Med Public Health. 2019; 6:286-89.
  6. Gul D, Sharma N. Socio-demographic profile, and pattern of substance abuse among patients presenting to a deaddiction center in a teaching hospital of Punjab. Indian J Psychiatry. 2021;63(1):80-83.
  7. Raghuvanshi G, Pathak U, Varma A, Singh AK. Socio-demographic and clinical profile of patients with substance use disorder at a tertiary care center in Vindhya region: A hospital-based study. J Clin Diagn Res. 2022; 16(5): 5-10.
  8. Sagar T. When it conquers your consciousness. Kerala calling. 2022; 42 (11); 20-21.
  9. UNODC, World Drug Report 2022, United Nations publication, 2022.
  10. Schifano F, Chappini S, Corkery JM, Guirguis A. Abuse of prescription drugs in the context of novel psychoactive substance (NPS): A systematic review. Brain Sci., 2018; 8: 73-90.
  11. Ambekar A, Agrawal A, Rao R, Mishra AK, Khandelwal SK, Chadda RK on behalf of the group of investigators for the National Survey on Extent and Pattern of Substance Use in India. The magnitude of Substance Use in India. New Delhi: Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment, Government of India. 2019.
  12. Singh OP. Substance use in India – Policy implications. Indian J Psychiatry. 2020;62(2):111.
  13. Economic review-2022 Government of Kerala, State Planning Board, Thiruvananthapuram. Vol 1. 2022.